Saturday, May 24, 2008

Favorite scene

What was your favorite scene from the book?

I really adored the scene where Elias, after realizing he was in love with the crippled Celeste, presented a hand-made comb to her. It's not a very good comb, but she acts like it's a rare treasure because he gave it to her. Aside from the food in her stomach and the clothes on her back and a little of nothing in a corner of her cabin, the comb was all she had. A child of three could have toted around all she owned all day long and not gotten tired. Then the comb instantly breaks the first time she uses it and Elias says, "Pay it no mind .. I'll make you a comb for every hair on your head." And Celeste, crying, says, ""Thas easy to say today cause the sun be shinin. Tomorrow, maybe next week, there won't be no sun, and you won't be studyin no comb."

The scene is comical but sad and moving because it underscores how fragile love is in general, but especially in their world, where despite their commitment to each other they can be torn apart. Elias is restless and adrift and can only think of escape until he gets close to Celeste and realizes that loving her can anchor him to life and give it purpose and beauty and passion. His love strengthens him (and her) and at the same time makes them poignantly vulnerable because it exposes a layer of tenderness that the world may or may not treat with care.

2 comments:

Erin said...

Yeah, that is a really good scene. And that's a lovely analysis of it.

I also liked the scene when skirt-chasing Stamford first approaches Delphie and asks her out, basically, and she feels pity for him. She winds up shutting the door in his face anyway, but we already know that she will eventually wind up marrying him and opening an orphanage in the city. Knowing their future together makes that scene kind of poignant.

kc said...

Yeah, that was a good scene.

I found all the Stamford stuff kind of unsettling. All the talk about "young stuff" made me think he was going to molest someone at every turn, so I wasn't very keen on reading at many points. But then he has that weird experience in the storm and seems to change. I didn't really follow that, and I didn't find his character development terribly persuasive.